The Equation Series
Menu

Energy · Profile from Energy Research Companion

Solyndra

The Fremont, California solar start-up that made panels from copper-indium-gallium-selenide (CIGS) thin film deposited on glass tubes, won the first loan guarantee of the 2009 stimulus programme — $535m — to build a highly automated factory, and filed for bankruptcy on 6 Sep 2011 after the price of the silicon it was designed to avoid fell by roughly nine-tenths. Its engineering worked; its cost position did not. Taxpayers lost ~$528m (DOE estimate), private investors ~$1bn+, ~1,100 workers lost their jobs, and "Solyndra" became the word every later US argument about industrial policy reaches for — from the 2011 House investigation to the Inflation Reduction Act's manufacturing credits and their 2025 rollback.

At a glance

Founded
May 2005, by Chris (Christian) Gronet, a former Applied Materials executive (reported); incorporated in California
Headquarters
Fremont, California (Fab 1 and the purpose-built Fab 2)
Ownership / structure
Private, venture- and family-office-backed; largest investors Argonaut Ventures (linked to the George Kaiser Family Foundation), Madrone Capital (linked to the Walton family), RockPort Capital, U.S. Venture Partners, CMEA and others (reported); ~$1bn+ of private equity and debt raised (reported)
Leadership
Chris Gronet (founder, CEO 2005–Jul 2010); Brian Harrison (CEO from 27 Jul 2010); W.G. "Bill" Stover (CFO) (reported)
Product
Cylindrical CIGS modules for flat commercial rooftops: 40 tubes per panel, light absorbed from direct, diffuse and reflected light, no tilt racking and no roof penetrations; cell efficiency ~12–14% flat (company spec, 2008, reported), module efficiency well below crystalline silicon
Scale
Revenue ~$100m (2009) and ~$140m (2010) (reported, verify); planned capacity 610 MW a year by 2013 (IPO filing, reported), cut to ~300 MW after Nov 2010; peak headcount ~1,100
Capital
DOE loan guarantee $535m (conditional commitment 20 Mar 2009, closed Sep 2009; funded by the Federal Financing Bank); Fab 2 cost ~$733m; ~$25.1m California sales-tax exclusion (reported)
End
Fremont plant shut 31 Aug 2011; Chapter 11 filed 6 Sep 2011 (Delaware); liquidating plan confirmed Oct 2012; building sold to Seagate (2013, reported)
Signature moves (incl. failures)
Founding and the cylindrical CIGS bet (2005); the first DOE stimulus loan guarantee (2009); the presidential visit and the withdrawn IPO (2010); Fab 2's opening and ramp (2010); Fab 1 closure and the price war (Nov 2010); the loan restructuring and subordination (Feb 2011); shutdown and Chapter 11 (2011); the investigations and the political legacy (2011–2026)

8 strategic moves analysed

Each one gets a full strategy file in the companion: context, the decision, the financing, what happened, and the lesson.

  1. 2005

    Founding and Cylindrical CIGS

    Founding / technology bet

  2. 2009

    DOE Loan Guarantee

    Financing (state support: federal loan guarantee)

  3. 2010

    Fab 1 Closure and the Price War

    Restructuring / strategy pivot

  4. 2010

    Fab 2 Opening and Ramp

    Construction or commissioning

  5. 2010

    Presidential Visit and Withdrawn IPO

    Spin-off or IPO (failed) / political

  6. 2011

    Investigations and the Political Legacy

    Regulatory or legal action

  7. 2011

    Loan Restructuring and Subordination

    Financing (restructuring of state-supported debt)

  8. 2011

    Shutdown and Chapter 11

    Restructuring or bankruptcy